AIDS got me thinking
D didn’t show any emotion while i was taking his medical history.
30 year old male, HIV positive when he was 17, full blown AIDS in 2003. to date, he has gone through quite a bit after it became full blown. he was supposed to see an ophthalmologist for a sudden blindness on his left eye. ridiculous as it may seem, blindness is not urgent enough for him to be granted a same day appointment. he was told the earliest appointment available is in september. he had no choice but to go to the ER.
although we do get full blown AIDS and HIV positive patients in our unit, they are not that common. understandably, the staff, mostly the RNs, are always curious as to how the disease was acquired.
it wasn’t a surprise when after i came out of the room, nurses flocked to me like hungry dogs awaiting a hefty meal. all with the same query: “so May, HOW did he get IT?”
“i don’t know. i didn’t ask. was i supposed to?” i replied coldly.
“does he look like a druggie? maybe one of those needles huh” M said.
“is he gay?” T asked.
“oh my God, i hope not from blood transfusion, it always makes me sad to hear that” L exclaimed.
i listened to them but didn’t say a thing. i acted busy doing D’s paperworks.
why don’t i ask THAT question? this is not the first time i’ve had an AIDS patient, and always, i never ask how they get it. most of the times, they eventually tell me without me asking.
i reckon it won’t make a difference; it doesn’t matter. but is it something deeper? am i afraid my own prejudices will make me a biased, judgmental nurse who would do differently if a patient somehow “chose” the lifestyle that led to the disease?
am i wrong to think that it doesn’t matter? is it hypocritical to think that the patient deserves the same care even if he has a “part” in being sick?
i remember taking care of A, an alcoholic drug addict who had a stroke at 37, and was paralyzed. almost everybody took care of him on auto pilot, smiling at family members, giving him everything he needs, but when his doors are closed, they all openly talk about how “he deserves everything that he is now”. i usually keep my distance when RNs discuss situations like these. when they air out their opinions about a smoker with lung cancer, an alcoholic with liver cirrhosis, a drug addict with AIDS, i keep quiet and cringe. i always thought i have no right to judge them, and therefore i am not in the position to conclude what “punishment” they should endure because of their choices.
do i really, honestly believe that, or am i the world’s biggest, fattest liar?


i’ve been a nurse for ten years. i decided a while back that it didn’t matter how people got in the situation they’re in, but recently i’ve found myself making extremely negative comments about morbidly obese patients and i wonder if it’s because it effects me directly, after all i’m the one who has to clean them, turn them etc.
Comment by Anonymous — June 23, 2005 @ 1:05 pm
*scrape* *scrape* *scrape*
That would be me dragging out my soapbox.
The best comment I ever heard about this sort of thing came from a nurse I knew who’d worked as a heart-lung transplant specialist for years. Even those folks who’d done something to “deserve” needing a transplant were, in her eyes, equally deserving of a transplant. Her rationale? Every single person on the planet gets a second chance at life every day, whether or not we recognize it. Therefore, who are we to judge?
I do occasionally judge people–especially those folks who are addicted or morbidly obese. But I try to refrain, both mentally and audibly, from doing so. After all, there but for the grace of God, and all that.
There is always, always something deeper in a person that facilitates an addiction, whether it’s to drugs, unsafe sex, tobacco, or food. Find that thing and you might find you’re not that different from them.
Comment by Jo — June 23, 2005 @ 3:38 pm
What a great post… I agree it does not matter how someone got HIV. Most of us have done things in our lives that could have infected us… how many of us, while now married and perhaps never promiscuous, cannot say that in our single days we dated and there were times when we had sex without a condom??? There was an article in this mornings local newspaper about a woman who is now in her 40’s. When she was 27, married for 5 years and contemplating beginning a family, was told she was HIV positive as a result of applying for life insurance. She admits in her younger days she was an IV drug user and had unprotected sex with many men. Now she works to educate others and hopefully in doing so protect them from such risky behaviors. It was an amazing article.
Comment by mamalife — June 23, 2005 @ 4:52 pm
I don’t think it matters how they got what they have, it’s how you do your job. Being a caregiver means just that. I dunno, it’s sad cause as much as you may understand all the things they need to do to be compliant they’re not always willing to change. if i had a pt. who was HIV positive-it wouldn’t matter to me. I’d hope I’d be compassionate and do my job-you may be the last person they see…they know their terminal and they’re afraid…i don’t see why a person would want to make someone’s last days hard for them…sad…just sad..all of it.
Comment by kimmyk — June 23, 2005 @ 6:55 pm
great post… i can only speak of my clinical experience since i’m a new grad. i’m sure i judged people - but i think it was more the people that i was working with than anyone else! when i would see the fear, loneliness, and/or pain in a patient’s eyes (and i can’t remember NOT seeing it), i felt the urgency to focus on how to help them through it rather than how they got it. and i’m grateful that i had clinical professors who took the same approach. i hope that your co-workers will someday (soon!) realize what they are doing.
Comment by marj — June 24, 2005 @ 5:12 am
i agree with the difficulty of taking care of obese patients, i literally want to cry once i get report that my patient is 400-500 pounds. it is really physically straining; but it doesn’t mean i think she/he deserves to die, does it? it sounds like a joke when my fellow RNs talk about it, but it still makes me uncomfortable. or as i said, maybe i’m just the world’s biggest hypocrite.
Comment by may — June 24, 2005 @ 9:10 am
I’m not much of an “asker,” either.
Comment by shrimplate — June 24, 2005 @ 12:13 pm
I don’t ask much, either. Once you’re sick, you’re sick, and I don’t think the virus really cares. I’m the one on my unit who usually primaries the attempted suicides, because i really don’t think it’s their fault. Plenty of nurses do, though.
Comment by Laura — June 24, 2005 @ 9:47 pm
With HIV/AIDS, I’m always curious as to how they got infected, but I never ask. But then, I’m curious about everyone’s history–if there’s ever a quiet moment, I’m the one reading charts or talking to patients for clarifications.
As far as judgements go…I try really, really hard not to be judgemental. Most of the time I succeed–but the one thing that gets me is people coming in repeatedly for drug/alcohol withdrawal. When they start going wild and need restraints, 1:1 supervision, haldol, etc, and then they get better, leave, and come back in a few months with the same thing….it makes me wish I could videotape the wildness to show them what they act like. It’s hard to understand how they can go out and drink/do drugs again.
Comment by JenSN — June 24, 2005 @ 10:52 pm
It sometimes escape us why people do what they do: eat till they bloat, drink till their livers shrink, hump around unprotected, etc. all in the name of pleasure and escapism. we all know that those people, like everyone else, got problems. It’s how they deal with them. We’re also aware that quitting is not easily done than said.
It’s not for us to question why they do what they do as for us to question ourselves why we think what we think.
We chose to be in the medical profession not because we wanted to pass up as judges brandishing stethoscopes with a law degree. We took up nursing or medical training because other than the title and salary, we aim to do what our profession requires us to do: heal and comfort the sick, take care of them and use the best of our knowledge to help them through their experience as healthily-challenged individuals.
Though at times we can’t help but do exactly the main thing that separates us from the law profession, we have to keep this in mind: that yeah,it’s a free country and we’re entitled to our sentences, verdicts and personal opinions (TV and movie actors do and some didn’t even land a 4X4 spot on college soil). That if you as a nurse/doctor can’t help harboring self-righteous/nasty thoughts on a patient, but if you just do your job and know how to keep your thoughts to yourself, make sure that it does not affect the way you care for your patient. If your prejudice gets in the way, I think it’s high time that you start looking at yourself from the inside.
As for you May, you are just being honest and noble. You go, girl!
Comment by Rebecca — June 25, 2005 @ 6:02 pm
This post has been removed by the author.
Comment by Cara — June 26, 2005 @ 7:30 pm
You know its easy to take care of people, but sometimes its just harder to have sympathy for those we feel like “got themselves into their own mess”. I definitely don’t agree with judging people, but like your nurse friend said, sometimes its much sadder to hear about people who didn’t “ask” to get into their situation. I actually just did a AIDS ethics poll on my blog. Check it out http://www.sedationisgood.com
Comment by Cara — June 26, 2005 @ 7:32 pm
Search for Cheap Insurance
Sorry, it just sounds like a crazy idea for me
Trackback by Search for Cheap Insurance — October 21, 2007 @ 5:50 am