THE boys debate
we did it because not doing it is not even an option. where i grew up, it is just done. to every male. period. decades ago, it was done by one old person without any medical training whatsoever, to boys ages 7-12. later, the choice of having it done in the hospital anytime came up.
i admit we did not even do a research if it has medical/physical benefits or disadvantages. i admit we never thought it was something our boys have a say about. i admit that as a mother, i actually thought it was best that they have it early, when they have no complete awareness of the experience, than have it later, when there are social reactions or opinions to deal with. i admit that i never thought they will actually decide against it, and by doing it early, i spared them a lot of trouble, and therefore, i am doing it at their best interest.
i admit our decision was mainly based on culture, no more no less. i am a christian, but that is not why we did it.
i admit we just went ahead without much thought about how our boys will think or believe in the future. now, i know that some people are thinking we “just played God” by cutting off a part of our boys’ bodies, but believe me, that is so far away from the truth.
i’m talking about circumcision. and yes, i am telling the world we had both our kids circumcised before they came home from the hospital, when they were both a week old. yes, i cried at the thought of them being cut and having pain, but it never occured to me not to have it done. and yes, i thought it was just the paranoid and overprotective mother in me who worried about the pain, when i saw that either of them didn’t really flinch more when i cleaned them post procedure, more than they flinched when i cleaned them after they pooped.
now, i may live in guilt for the rest of my life. with all the issues coming out of nowhere, as pointed out by one of the blogosphere’s respected pediatricians, other people now view my decision as questionable, and my intentions as debatable. it is never an issue in the philppines, where i came from, but it is an issue here, where the kids were born.
i now live in fear that somewhere in the future, one of my boys will come home, furious and eternally resentful that we did not wait till they reach the age of reason and let them decide what they want with their penises.
will telling my kids we did it because it is the only and best thing know about male babies when they were born be enough? will telling them i and their father decided on instinct and culture when we had it done be explanation enough? will they accept it to be reasonable, that we honestly thought that we were doing them a favor, would that be enough?
another respectable blogger/physician who happened to be a filipino pointed out very clearly that culture is reason enough. will that reasoning be enough for our kids? will they forgive us and say, “well…dad, mom, we hated it that you just thought about yourself and your culture, but we understand you now, and we are happy you did something to remind us where we really came from.”
the idea that some people who don’t agree with our decision bothers me somehow, but it is not something i can’t handle. their animosity and judgment i can live with. however, the thought that my kids will hate me for the rest of their lives because i decided to do what i thought was best at the time i made that decision scares and pains me beyond words. meanwhile, there is no other way but to hope they will accept our explanations wholeheartedly in the future.
i don’t know, but it is in my best interest that i think this happy ending is possible. after all, i cannot undo what we have done, and i cannot live in guilt everyday and still be an effective parent.


You didn’t play God, God-forbid. This is the kind of heated rhetoric I wish were kept out of the circ-debate.
best,
Flea
Comment by Flea — August 22, 2006 @ 7:41 am
dr. flea, i edited that line that originally said..”i admit we just played God…”in paragraph 4, because i meant to enclose that line “playing God” with parenthesis, meaning some people think that, but we actually don’t. i hope that made it clearer. thanks for stopping by…
Comment by may — August 22, 2006 @ 8:07 am
To circumsize or not is just one of the many, many decisions we make as parents. All decisions we make are the best at the time, and of course there are going to be some wrong decisions in hind sight (not to say that circumsion is wrong). We can only do the best we can, and hopefully be forgiven for our mistakes.
Comment by annemiek — August 23, 2006 @ 4:36 am
I can only speak for myself but as a circumcised male, I doubt very much that your kids will hate you. Very rarely I have thought about it, but unemotionally, and I have no sense of having been taken advantage of, and I am glad it was done while I was a baby. Maybe someone complained on the news or somesuch but the overwhelming majority of my friends were circumcised and are happy and well and I have never met anyone who took issue with their circumcision. Please be reassured you never have to think about it.
Comment by Dom — August 23, 2006 @ 6:48 am
If they blame you, you can always cite the health benefits. But that is far-fetched. You are a loving mother. I never, for a moment, suspect that your sons will be angry at you in the future.
Comment by Emer — August 25, 2006 @ 1:47 am
You made a decision based on many things, none of them wrong. it’s an issue about which some people have very strong feelings, and with such things part of the validation of those strong feelings requires attacking those who disagree. The fact is there are billions of males on the planet over time who’ve been circumcised. All but a tiny few have no problem with it. And medically speaking, there are clearly more problems with those who aren’t circumcised. Your kids will be fine. No pun intended: for the vast majority of people, it’s a small thing. There are many more serious things in life. That you are so honest and concerned means you’re a great mom. Your kids are lucky.
Comment by Sid Schwab — August 28, 2006 @ 5:03 pm
I tink in dis world, ther r alota tings 2 worry bout than circumcision, if ppl live by there religion thats there right hu r v 2 interfere, if sum1 is worried bout mutilation den look @ da situation in da world an c how many ppl r mutilated.apologies 2 al
Comment by Amla — February 21, 2007 @ 3:31 pm