reflective practice
“WHAT’S YOUR NAME?”
i pulled my badge out and showed her my last name, after saying “May”. she was so mad, she was shaky. while i was holding out my badge, she wrote what i assumed was my name in her little piece of paper.
there is something about being asked your name loudly, and being told, nonverbally, that you are in big trouble. it made me giddy. sadly, not giddy enough to apologize. so i kept quiet. the whole night, i saw her, walk past through her, and all i have given her was silence.
i don’t know her name, but i’ll call her Snarly, she was the daughter of the patient in bed 1, who wasn’t my patient. P, my 26 year old mentally retarded patient was in bed 2. Snarly was allowed to stay at the bedside overnight because her mom didn’t speak a word of english. since i started my shift, she reeked of cigarette and had somebody with her whom she chatted with endlessly. once, i saw her waking up her mom in the mddle of a rather peaceful sleep, sounding like she was asking if she was okay. her mother, disturbed, would answer “si”, a signal for her to leave for her smoke break.
P wore a helmet, because it was her habit to hit her head either on the side rails, or with her hands, occasionally. no reason for the hitting, she will just do it for a few minutes, 5 minutes was the longest i noticed, and then stop. she will then sleep for two to three hours, and wake up to do the hitting again, coupled with those incomprehensible sounds that do sound like moaning.
Snarly complained to H (her mother’s nurse) at about 9 pm, saying that her mom can’t sleep because of the moaning, and asked “can’t her nurse give her anything?” i told the nurse what she already knew. my patient was not in pain, she was not agitated, i will not give her any kind of narcotic just to knock her out. there is no medicne i can give her to stop her from hitting her head. irritated, i added: “they should be grateful she is like that, because at least she doesn’t complain about them talking endlessly, and coming in and out smelling like a burning lobe of lung.”
at 0130, Snarly was not in her chair when i went to see my patient, who was sleeping like a baby. at 0137, Snarly was at the door, both her arms accross her chest, looking rather…well, snarly. she started pacing in front of the door, an action that led H to save her face and call out my name, making sure Snarly heard her. making sure Snarly heard me, i responded rather…well, snarly: “what do you want me to do H?” then, i asked the charge nurse: “is there a way we can transfer my patient to another room?”
this is the part where Snarly snapped and walked right in front of me, shaking, asking my name. after putting the paper in her pocket, she asked “can’t you at least check on her because she has been doing that for a while maybe she is in pain maybe she needs something just go there at least.”
“i just checked her….” i looked at the clock and it was just 7 minutes ago, but i kept my mouth shut.
“when? she has been doing THAT for a LOOONNGG time!”
i walked past through Snarly without a word, and went straight to the room. i stood at the bedside, whispered “it’s okay P” a couple of times. P did not even see me, but as expected, she stopped hitting her head, and was quiet again.
after that, between Snarly and me, the silence was deafening. maybe i should have, but as i said, i did not apologize.
_______________________
it has been a week. what did she do with that piece of paper? i have not heard from the nurse manager. not heard anything from patient relations. not even anything from the charge nurse.
what has writing my name in a piece of paper accomplish?
intimidation? threat?
________________________
it’s called reflective practice. to look back on a certain situation and analyze what you have done. play out the previous scenes in your head and find out why you did what you did. reflect and see if you could have done better. then, do better next time.
well, if i listened to my mean, bitchy self, i would say i have done better if i said…
”look Snarly, i don’t care if you want to die of lung cancer. i don’t even care if you dote on your mother to the point of literal suffocation. most importantly, i don’t care if you disrespect my patient’s right to have a peaceful night by yakking your night away with your brother or husband or friend. all i care about is that you should at least have a little understanding and patience towards my patient. it is not my patient’s fault that she is mentally retarded and does not know that there are other ways to express herself other than hitting her head. i know you are important, but that does not give you the right to get angry with my patient just because she is being herself. do you understand? do you?”
only, my bitchy self is supposed to be getting older now, and this is supposed to be the time when i’m expected to be more understanding and mellow. so, i know i could have done better if i said…
“Snarly, i deeply apologize for disturbing your mother. i understand you want the best for her and it must be very frustrating to see her awake when all you want is for her to have a good rest and get better. i will do everything within my power to calm my patient down. if needed, i will put her on restraint just so she will stop hitting her head, so you, your visitor, and your mother, can have a peaceful sleep. i assure you, i will not hesitate in giving her the maximum dose of ativan just so she will get zonked and you can rest. thank you for being so patient and i again, i apologize. i hope that a pack of cigarette from our unit will appease your anger, and will let you know how sincerely sorry i am.”
____________________
somehow, something doesn’t sound right.
let me sleep on it. i might come up with a better “next time” scenario.
i love reflective practice. i do it all the time. i honestly think it is very useful. sometimes, after a decent amount of time reflecting, i come up with brilliant ideas. sometimes, i come up with nothing. i guess i’m just too tired to reflect sensibly at this time, because it’s pretty obvious i came up with nothing.
…but seriously, i do intend to be a better nurse. any suggestions on how i could have handled this situation better? i don’t want my name in a piece of paper next time. not like that anyway.


For me, the hardest part of being a nurse is dealing with visitors like that. I mean it. I probably would not have handled it as well as you did. So many times, we just have to hold our tongue. I had a situation the other night where I was confronted by a family member who was very accusatory. It ruined my whole night by putting me behind because I spent so much time trying to answer her many questions. I think she may have written my name down, too as she glared at me when I told her I had to leave (to take care of my other patients!!). That’s what I get for trying to be helpful. I should have just said “I’ll call the doctor and you can speak with him about your concerns.” thanks for letting me rant a little…
Comment by RN — February 11, 2007 @ 12:30 pm
It’s interesting, isn’t it, how the negative encounters carry so much more weight than the positive ones, even though the good ones way out-number the others. I suppose they’re the ones we learn from the most; and it seems like you’re trying to learn from this one. Even though it seems the one who really needs the lesson is Ms. Snarly.
Comment by Sid Schwab — February 11, 2007 @ 9:17 pm
There’s just no right way to deal with some people. Looks to me like the toughest part of being a nurse isn’t the patients, but their family and friends.
Comment by Donna — February 12, 2007 @ 2:38 am
i agree with donna. you could give me a dozen demented, mentally retarded or even psychotic patients and i can deal with them very easily. but family and relatives?! NO WAY! yes, there are a few who are thankful and appreciative with nurses but there are some who thinks that we are their slaves or something! i couldn’t have dealt with Snarly the way you did. so what if she had written your name in a piece of paper?! she could have written mine in the wall for all i care. as long as i know that i didn’t do anything to compromise my patient’s or even her mother’s health, i won’t give a damn about her. your patients are lucky to have you as a nurse so don’t bother even thinking about Snarly the WITCH! ha ha ha…
Comment by Drei — February 12, 2007 @ 9:52 am
Reading it through, it seems like you couldn’t have done much more. Some people can’t be satisfied.
And please don’t tell me she was a lawyer!
Comment by The Curmudgeon — February 12, 2007 @ 12:25 pm
Since she was *obviously* the most important person in the hospital at the time, i imagine that no matter what you could have done–except maybe lavished the attention and devotion on her that she so obviously deserved–you still probably would have ended up with a cranky, bitchy woman on your hands.
Some peoples is just insufferable.
(Hope the snark and sarcasm comes across there.)
Comment by Ursa — February 13, 2007 @ 7:47 am
Give me a heads up here, what is this age I should be looking out for (and looking forward to) where dimwits no longer bother me and I won’t lose my temper?
I sure hope it hasn’t went on by and I missed it.
Comment by SUrgeon in my Dreams — February 13, 2007 @ 11:09 am
Sometimes when my caffeine level is at full, I approach these folks when I see them giving me the eyeball. I have found being on the offense will take the Snarlys and Snarkys of the world by surprise and can diffuse a situation before your name is written down.
If that doesn’t work, I suggest instituting the aerial spraying of Ativan for all..lol.
Comment by AzRN — February 13, 2007 @ 11:23 pm
When I was an ICU nurse there was an old joke that the best time to work was at night with an intubated orphan.
Sadly there is some truth there!
Having likewise been threatened with the “what’s you name” tactic many times and had a number of letters actually written, I can more than appreciate what you’ve written here! The one thing I have learned from it all is that yes, sometimes there are things that I could have done better.
But the flaw of so called reflective practice is that you can take that process to far!
I know too many nurses; myself included, who tend to blame themselves for anything that goes wrong. We seem to collectively have a habit similar to that of many abuse victims in that we automatically assume responsibility for everything. It’s always are fault! But guess what, it’s not! Sometimes (most times I suspect) people are just demanding jerks and usually the worst offenders are the “concerned family members”.
Don’t spend anymore time on this one and be kind to yourself.
Comment by angrynurse — February 15, 2007 @ 8:28 am
Well, perhaps I’m in the minority here, but when I get the “WHAT’S YOUR NAME” question
1)I pleasantly tell the person I’ll get them a business card, which I do (we have generic business cards with the ER information on them) and
2)pleasantly tell them that I’m writing my name on the back, which I do because I want to make sure they spell it correctly, and
3)then ask if there were any other staff members whose names they needed. No?
4)”Well, here is my card, with my manager’s number right on the front. You can call or write her anytime. Is there anything else I can do for you right now? No? Well feel free to let me know if you think of anything you need.”
Not a single letter has ever been written.
Comment by Kim — February 15, 2007 @ 5:56 pm
Unfortunately, that kind of situation comes with nursing. If you hadn’t worked that night, she would have gone after whatever nurse was in your place. The problem wasn’t you, it was her. Sometimes nursing sucks.
Comment by Melissa — February 17, 2007 @ 9:03 pm
You did absolutely right by biting your tongue - just as long as it didn’t bleed. Sometimes the cold treatment is what this kind of people deserve. Silence can be as cruel as it is kind. You didn’t evidently try to hurt or maim her feelings.
If you apologized to her in behalf of your noisy patient who obviously can’t help it, it would only reinforce her nasty behaviour and the quickest way to a job burnout. Bitchiness is best when you are only a few days from retirement. So chill. LOL!!!
Comment by howling — February 18, 2007 @ 4:33 am
I think ya handled yourself well May. Sometimes ya just can’t win. But you did good. Maybe next time to show you don’t care if they ask your name, maybe offer to write it down for them so at least they get the spelling right or something. LOL.
Comment by kimmyk — February 18, 2007 @ 6:02 am
“Reflective practice” is about “learning” learning how to deal with social life that is fluid, changing and unpredictable. One important tool that helps us to be a reflective practitioner is being able to analyse other people’s perspective. People see things (very the same things) from different perspectives and they act based on what they see. It is hard for us to realise what their perspective might be, but it’s easy to explain ours in order to help them gain our perspectives. This is what you did in first scenario, starting with” Look Snarly I don’t care……”
This is the first step and an important one in dead to open the lines of communication as a reflective practitioner, the next would be trying to get their perspective in which there may be many things to learn about
Comment by Yadolah Zarezadeh — February 18, 2007 @ 7:28 am
Forgive me, but I seem to be looking at this situation in a different way. As an RN, I agree that visitors/family members like these can be a handfull. On the other hand, I think you are missing the whole point of the story you just told us. You said that P stopped hitting her head after just a few minutes of your consoling her. That to me is a big clue. She may not have been in pain, but she was probably scared to death. After all, she’s in a strange setting, and doesn’t understand what’s happening to her. I would be willing to bet all she really needed was someone to reassure her in a soothing voice.
I fall into this very trap myself when family members approach me, but I have learned to deal with it quite effectively by following one simple rule - before I react, I stop and ask myself if I have missed anything, or if there is anything I could do differently. More often than not I will think of something else I can do to alleviate the situation.
Comment by Joe — February 19, 2007 @ 5:30 am
Joe,
thanks for dropping by. let me make myself clearer: P hits her head as a habit. she does it even in her house, where it is not a strange place, and she is not with strange people. that is why she is wearing a helmet 24/7. i don’t think i am missing the whole point, which to me is this: when our family gets sick, we get stressed, sometimes that stress causes us to be self centered and impatient about others. although i understand that behavior, i have to be honest and say it gets very challenging to deal with, especially if i have my patient’s best interest in mind. that is the whole point, although i will definitely respect it if you don’t agree.
Comment by may — February 19, 2007 @ 8:19 pm
I definitely understand the frustrations that are generated by dealing with family members. Like I said, I have fallen into that trap, and it almost ended in serious disaster for me. I was spendindg so much time and energy on the family member that I almost lost track of my patient. That is when I learned to double check myself before I get into the thick of things with the family members. I find it accomplishes two things at once- it double checks my work (I tend to be compulsive that way, always “rethinking” what I have done, or what I should have done) and it gives the family member some sense that I am not ignoring them. (Sometimes that is all it takes for them to be satisfied) Unfortunately it doesn’t work in every case, but it seems to help me most of the time.
Also, I did not mean to imply that you didn’t have your patient’s best interest in mind. I apologize if that’s the way it came across. One of my duties in the position I have right now is to examine every incident/complaint from a Quality Improvement perspective, which forces me to examine everything from just about every conceivable angle, and present all the possibilites to the “Team Leaders” for review.
Comment by Joe — February 19, 2007 @ 9:36 pm
Why _is_ it that we take so much abuse from patient’s families and think it is “normal?” Why do we as a profession tend to think we are the ones to blame? I ask myself these questions over and over and over.
A few years ago I had a patient’s aunt threaten to kill me. The patient was shot in a gang related incident and I worked in a rough part of a big city. You better believe I took her seriously, even though I did nothing wrong.
Being the convenient target for anger and frustration needs to be something we help protect each other from. Too bad there isn’t an easy solution.
Comment by emily — February 25, 2007 @ 11:26 am
You can please all the patients some of the time….
You can please some of the patients all of the time….
But… you can NEVER please the Family.
Comment by 10mgiv — March 6, 2007 @ 6:54 am
I liked Kim’s suggestion above [Feb 15th] which said to give Snarly a business card. You could also respond by making sure you take their names as well, recording time and date in an obvious way. I’d probably bring them a ‘complaints form’ and suggest I helped them fill it in. Hopefully there’s a place which asks them what they would like to see done and you could talk them through it. I’m sure they wouldn’t swear, but if they did, you would have to include it. They may come up with a brilliant idea that no one else has ever thought of! [Build a new wing that is sound-proofed with loads of extra staff], they may even offer to pay for it.
Anyway, you’ll know when you’ve reflected on this to a satisfactory level, because you’ll probably look back and not get worked up about it.
Comment by Maggie — March 10, 2007 @ 11:48 am