mother and daughter
“i’ve been through all that three years ago. thanks to my daughter, i am still here.”
i did sense the sarcasm, and was about to let it go, but she was not ready to let me go, so i asked if she didn’t really feel grateful to be alive.
“i tell you, it is more of a curse than a blessing. let’s just say that i hate dialysis with a burning passion. you think that can explain why i am so angry at my daughter for asking the doctors to do EVERYTHING just to keep me alive back then? i mean, six months i was in the hospital. a couple of months on that ventilator, and i can’t even tell them i would really have loved to go. you know, dying would have been better. but my daughter? she wanted EVERYTHING done. now, waiting for a kidney, you think i love waiting?”
i was silent for a moment. it would have been better if i stayed that way, but i was still cleaning her up after administering that 30 ml of antibiotic to her bladder through her urethra (which, to be honest, freaked me out at first because i have never done it before), so i sort of spoke in behalf of her daughter. i told her i would have done the same if i were in her daughter’s shoes.
“well, i was 64 back then, it would have been perfectly alright for me to go. i still haven’t really forgiven her, and i don’t think i ever will. i hope it never happens again. i hope this time i made it VERY clear to her that i do not want to be resuscitated again. never again. ever.”
she asked how cloudy the urine was, the urine that came out just before i administered the antibiotic. i told her it was cloudy. she wanted to see it, but i told her it was with the rest of the trash. she knew i didn’t really want her to see it.
“i bet you it’s like milk. you think with all these modern drugs and all, they can fix this infection. i don’t believe that anymore. i mean, antibiotics of all kinds for the past three months, and i still pee droplets of urine as white as milk, i pee every 30 minutes. and you would think i should never pee anymore, i mean, both my kidneys are supposed to be extremely messed up. why am i still peeing? and why am i still here?”
what do i say to that? nothing. so i didn’t say anything. i nstead, i covered her up, and turned off the light. i told her to have a good night, and to call me if she needed any help.
“if she just let me go, i won’t be suffering all these….”
how times change. it used to be that people are grateful to be given a second shot at life. no matter how difficult that life is after a near death experience. i mean, three years of being able to live, that should at least mean something good, right? wrong.
what i’m saying is, although i don’t totally understand her, i won’t say i don’t really undertsnad her. i guess it all depends now. it all depends on something, or on a lot of things.
as for her daughter, i wonder how she handles the emotional battle of being blamed that she wanted her mother to live longer. to be blamed for a day is one thing, but for three years, nonstop? it must be tough. imagine having to make that decision, thinking at that very moment, that you were making the best decision ever. success must have been sweet, and she might have even called it a miracle. she must have emotionally savored that time when her mother finally made it thorugh the crisis and lived.
sadly, that feeling of success was only for a fleeting second. it must be hard to be on her shoes. to be told that she screwed up by not letting her mother die. being a daughter, that kind of screwing up must be one of the toughest screw ups.
i went home confused. confused on what to feel or think about my patient’s very angry attitude. confused if i said the right thing by implying i agreed with her daughter and disagreed with her, but not really.
i also went home feeling sorry for my patient’s daughter. at the same time, i felt grateful that i didn’t have to wear her shoes.
sometimes, you never reallize how ideas of gratitude can come out from a busy 12 hour night shift. you think you just go to work to get by, to help. you don’t expect to find things to be grateful for. especially from an unusual story. but you find it. you find ideas. they come, and you never forget them.


Wow, what a difficult situation. Bless your heart, I know that was hard on you. As for me, sometimes when I get into these situations, I just don’t know what to feel because it’s so ambiguous and confusing…..
Comment by The Bohemian Road Nurse — June 7, 2007 @ 7:19 pm
I’m certainly no expert, but if I had to guess I would say all that anger is misplaced. She is probably angry at herself (ot at life in general) for being in the condition she is in and instead of recognizing all that self-anger she is projecting it onto her daughter.
Comment by PD Warrior — June 8, 2007 @ 4:03 am
Hospice.
Comment by shrimplate — June 8, 2007 @ 8:37 am
It’s amazing to me how people can redirect their energies and place blame when need be. I sympathize with this mother, however She must know that right now she’s killing herself. I can’t imagine having that guilt on me as a daughter. And I’m sure she cannot imagine living with the same guilt as her daughter had she made the same decision for her. I hope her wishes are known to everyone now….including her daughter.
Comment by Shanell RN — June 9, 2007 @ 1:36 pm
Most of us would choose “Life” all the time in every situation, but I guess it always ends up with the consent of the person whether he/she would want to end her life then just to end the suffering. It’s not her daughter who goes through all those procedures. But still the mother doesn’t have the right to blame her daughter for what she thought was right. I think instead of blaming she should have just focused her thoughts on being happy with her family and not on the procedures, it would be less painful that way
Comment by Ferdz — June 12, 2007 @ 8:22 am
This is a story that reminds me the mind/body/spirit connection should never be ignored. There are many broken spirits that are never repaired and the damage done presents itself as a medical problem. An in-depth social history could provide insight that might help both this patient and her daughter find peace. Perhaps we should add as a benefit for joining ranks with health care professionals: you will find the meaning of life in unlikely places.
Onehealthpro
Comment by Onehealthpro — June 16, 2007 @ 3:36 pm
I’ve just come upon your blog, it’s very interesting. I hope you don’t mind my stopping to comment. This woman sounds like she felt ready to go. She had reached the point of acceptance, and wanted the peace and freedom from caring for her tired body. It makes it so hard on them when they feel ready, yet their families are not. You sound like an exceptional nurse. Nice to have visited.
Comment by Chrysalis Angel — June 22, 2007 @ 5:45 pm