the incident report
the gauze dressing was soaked with blood, so i changed it. i was not ready to see her wound, so it sort of shocked me that it looked so nasty. her whole little finger was lacerated from it’s base to the tip, and i was sure i saw her little bones. i cringed at the sight and breathed that sigh of relief again: “thank God it wasn’t me!”
i then tried my best to convince the doctor for an xray, because in my untrained eyes, i was sure that her bones in that little finger were all broken. the doc was sure it was just a laceration, and will just need a few stitches. no matter how much i hoped he was right, i had this stinging feeling in my gut that it was much worse. a few days and ten stitches later, i was so glad to know that i was wrong.
it happened when i went to the restroom. i came back to see other nurses in my patient’s room. she was on the floor. her frail 86 year old body did not cooperate. hit by an extremely bad case of urinary tract infection, she had the urge to pee every hour or so. stubbornly independent, she wouldn’t hear of suggestions to use a diaper or a bed pan. unfortunately, i agreed with her.
she spoke spanish only, but we sort of had an understanding about when she wanted to go. we were okay the whole night, we managed. then, she fell on the last 15 minutes of my shift.
there were a number of reasons why i stuck to my decision not to ask the doctor for a foley catheter, or for restraints. i felt very strongly about my decision that i ignored everyone and was annoyed by their unsolicited, redundant advice for me to call the doctor. i told myself that i didn’t care about what they say, i just cared about my patient.
first of all, i did not question the doctors’ decision about the absence of the catheter because i did agree that it will only be a possible source of further worsening of her already bad infection. i am old schooled like that, and i am not embarassed to admit it.
secondly, it irritated me to no end that others have blatantly suggested restraints just because she was not independently able to get out of bed to the commode. they implied that because she kept on trying to be independent despite her unsteady gait was a proof that she was confused. i looked at those who were concerned with a set of weary and questioning eyes. although i answered them with complete cold silence, deep inside, i complained about their insensitivity to those who are aged and weak. i reasoned inwardly that it was inhuman to restraint her just because i wanted to save time and energy. it was true that she always needed my assistance and she ate up most of my time, and i am not going to be hypocritical about the fact that it was tiring, but i did not see why that was enough reason for me to demand an order for a restraint. it would have been something that i can easily convince the docs to order, but i never considered it, so i never called for it.
when she fell, because i was out and i was not there to answer to her call immediately, judging, disgusted eyes were on me. some even had the audacity to actually say it outloud: “this would never have happened if she had a foley or she was restrained!”
the thing about pseudoguilt is that it used to consume my entire system, i cannot just ignore it. the thing about time is that it teaches people how to go around the idea of pseudoguilt and turn it around. i know now that i am not what i used to be. i stood there looking at her bleeding forehead, and i realized that i was only guilty for a couple of seconds. i thought it was stupid of me to stick to my guts and idealistic craziness, but the bottom line is that i still felt like i did not do something wrong. i acknowledged the reality that the situation was beyond my control, and it was not my fault she fell.
in the middle of my arrogant, self proclaimed innocence, i heard the the patient’s loud, painful: “AWW AWW AWW AWW!” one of the nurses who was tyring to help her up accidentally ran the bed’s wheel over her little finger.
when she was settled back to bed, the nurse kept saying she felt horrible. she cleaned the wound and dressed it twice. then, over and over, she kept saying she felt horrible. in my head, i kept saying “oh my God, thank you it wasn’t me!” clearly, it has nothing to do with my inability to empathize with my patient’s terrible situation. it was a truthful admission that i was relieved not to be subjected to that kind of genuine guilt.
if i was the one who moved the bed and accidentally ran the patient’s finger over, i swear i will still be wallowing in the worst kind of self blame that i would have ended up eating a whole bag of chips ahoy daily, just so i can sugarcoat the deadly guilt. i know others might think i am exagerrating this, but i’m not. others may even think i am making a big deal out of such a small thing, but i’m not. i hate it that i am this honest when it comes to blogging my issues here, but it is what it is, and i do not really expect everyone to understand all of me and my absurdities.
there are a lot of things i discover about myself everyday. most of them amuse me. there are times however when i realize i am this horrible perosn who couldn’t care less about others, that even i, am appalled at my own selfishness. i wish i can apologize to O, the nurse who accidentally hurt my patient, for thanking God it was her who accidentally messed up, but i can’t, so i didn’t. everything happened so fast in my head, i really did not have the time to explain and expose my evil side to her.
the fact that when i told this story to my husband, he kept quiet and looked away, did not help me. he might be thinking a totally different thing, but with the crazies like me, i have concluded he was thinking he couldn’t believe i could be THAT self-centered. the other fact that there are a number of fires going on around here, is just making matters worse.


When I am 86 and frail, I hope you are my nurse and not your co-workers. You are right, it is inhumane to restrain someone and put them in diapers simply for convenience. How degrading that would be. Good luck with the fires; I’ve been hearing about them on the news - frightening stuff.
Comment by Lisa — October 22, 2007 @ 5:29 pm
kuddos to you for being a patient advocate!!!! to do something like a foley or restraints because of inconvience of the nurses is an absurd idea, and i for one am proud to have you as a fellow nurse. you did the right thing for the patient. as far as the guilt thing, if pays to be selfish at times…it is how we stay sane i believe, and the evil sides in check.
Comment by melissa — October 22, 2007 @ 6:05 pm
May -
I admire your honesty. Please don’t ever cover it up out of shame. Your honesty helps the rest of us in ways you do not know.
I do feel very sorry for your patient. That had to be painful and technically, yes, it could have been avoided. But I am constantly amazed at the number of people who don’t realize how painful it is to lose your independence. That is something that should be taken away only if absolutely positively necessary.
One thing I have noticed about some nurses is that they are very quick to point out what others did wrong or what they would have done differently. I mean, I’m just in school right now but I actually feel bad for some of the nurses I work with at the hospital - they are good nurses. They care about their patients. But inevitably, other nurses will make comments if the least little thing is not perfect.
I’m learning that a good nurse is not always the one who does everything perfectly.
Comment by A reader — October 22, 2007 @ 8:48 pm
[…] may placed an interesting blog post on the incident report.Here’s a brief overview:it happened when i went to the restroom. i came back to see other nurses in my patient’s room. she was on the floor. her frail 86 year old body did not cooperate. hit by an extremely bad case of urinary tract infection, she had the urge … […]
Pingback by www.cellulitediary.info » the incident report — October 23, 2007 @ 5:27 am
A couple of things: I’m with Lisa. I can’t say it better than she did: “When I am 86 and frail, I hope you are my nurse and not your co-workers.”
Next, don’t worry about apologizing to O — she didn’t hear you think. Nor was it “evil” to think that, it was merely human. Your subsequent remorse at even having that thought is more probative of your true qualities than that momentary, instinctive reaction.
OK?
Comment by The Curmudgeon — October 23, 2007 @ 11:18 am
I think it was compassionate of you to try to help her retain her dignity and independence.
Feelings are feelings. We can’t help what thoughts come up. But we can learn from them and make appropriate choices when presented.
Comment by SeaSpray — October 24, 2007 @ 11:10 pm
May,
As usual, you treated your patient with dignity and respect. It’s obvious you had her best interest at heart no matter what those other nurses said.
And as for your evil thoughts, you are only human. Believe me, if you could record some of the things that cross my mind at work…
Take care,
M.
Comment by unsinkablemb — October 25, 2007 @ 12:19 am
Way off-topic: October 27th would have been Sylvia Plath’s 75th birthday had she not dies tragically at age 30.
Comment by shrimplate — October 25, 2007 @ 5:33 am
Of course we’ve all had patients whose urge to urinate was not alleviated by the presence of a urinary catheter. And we’ve also had patients get itno trouble trying to get out of bed despite restraints.
Patients do not have falls because of lack of foleys or restraints. They fall because staffing levels are as low as possible.
Hospitals would rather suffer the expense and pain of a patient fall than hire more staff.
Comment by shrimplate — October 25, 2007 @ 5:46 am
I know that kind of guilt, too. You are not alone.
Comment by RN — October 25, 2007 @ 9:22 pm
May, first I agree with Curmudgeon that when I’m in the hospital, I would pick you over your co workers, as my nurse, I can so relate to why you are glad it wasn’t you. I also have guilt issues, and wear my heart on my sleeve. When my loved one, my best friend Ardis was dying in a hospice last August, I smashed her leg between the bed rail and the bed. I still to this day do not know how she managed to let her leg slide that far off the bed without me noticing, but it did. And it was because I had begged the hospice nurses to wait as long as possible before they placed a foley, because I knew she hated them. So I asked her when I noticed she was awake at 4 am, and she nodded that she needed the bedside commode. I don’t understand , did your patient have a bedside? Anyway, I smashed it, and thought it would bruise and it didn’t. I don’t know how, cause her gums were already bleeding from her liver failing, and the nurse told me her platelets were gone. Yes she was very drugged with roxynol, yes, she shook her head no when I asked her over and over did I hurt her, and there was no bruise. God saved my butt, because even though I was her medical proxy, they would not have trusted me anymore. in the end, I was alone in the room when she went to heaven. I don’t remember how many beers I drank trying to drown my guilt.
Comment by Bobby — October 25, 2007 @ 9:29 pm
Mary, thoughts don’t count. Actions do. Your actions are what this patient will be remembering, and they’ll be positive memories.
Comment by Chuck McKay — October 26, 2007 @ 12:07 am
I think it is great you made such an effort to help this lady out. And obviously you were having a pretty good night to be able to be in her room so often to help. I wish I were as fortunate. I am usually running from room to room and probably would have actually thought about restraints. But since she was alert and oriented I would have just given her a bedside commode and charted several times that she was aware of my wishes to use the call light for assistance. Then when they fall, I have at least done all I could without restraining and foley-ing. You can’t just tie everybody up! Especially if they are just stubborn–not confused. Don’t feel guilty. But I feel for you, because you prob had to stay late writing an incident report. Glad she wasn’t hurt bad..I think you are a great nurse. With real feelings and am glad you are not ashamed to admit them.
Comment by nocturnalRN — October 26, 2007 @ 10:12 am
Bravo!! I wish there were more nurses like you. I am the ADON of my facility - a long term care facility. Some people would call my facility a “nursing home,” but it is so much more than that. It is a place where people come to live, not to die. We area restraint free facility, meaning a doctor can order all the restraints he/she wants, but they will not be applied without a “team meeting” including representatives from all departments; nursing, socialwork, dietary, clergy, housekeeping, and maintenance to determine if there was anything else that could be done, or if the restraint really should be applied. In all the years I have been there we have never opted for the restraint,mainly because we can not make it past the last question; “Is the restraint for the benefit of the patient, or for the convenience of staff?”
Our safety care plans assume that everyone will fall eventually, and the goal is to decrease the frequency of falls, minimize injury, and maintain patient dignity.
I applaud you for your sincerity, and your dedication to the “whole” patient, promoting their sense of dignity and independence.
Comment by PD Warrior — October 27, 2007 @ 1:45 am
I would rather be independent and fall than be restrained and “safe”. You did good work.
Comment by canoehead — November 4, 2007 @ 2:41 am