there is a time to die, but no time to cry
monday night, she was smiling.
after i gave her enema, she smiled. after i gave her a heparin shot, she smiled. after i repositioned her, even in obvious pain, she smiled.
i think it was not because she was elated with the things i did to her. it was just because there was nothing else to do. she only spoke hindi, and i have no clue what she was talking about when she did talk.
so, she smiled.
i had to call her daughter in the middle of the night when she refused the second enema. after talking to her daughter for a few minutes, she passed the phone back to me, nodded and motioned me to go on. then, that smile.
granted that the sad result of her EGD came back that night, and the hateful tumor was labeled malignant, but still. she was not one of those patients who reeked of death. she was weak, yes. but dying? that did not even cross my mind when i left tuesday morning.
when i came back tuesday night, i was a little surprised that her name was not on my patient list, but i was not concerned. i thought they either moved her to a basic unit, or worse, to ICU.
then, they told me she died.
i wanted to cry. out of shock, out of empathy to her very enthusiastic daughter who filled me in with every little details of her mom’s life in the few minutes that we chatted. the sense of sadness that overtook me was the kind that daughters share when they lose their mom.
i wanted a moment. a minute or two maybe, just to be sad, because that was how it was, sad.
unfortunately, my job didn’t give me the luxury of that moment. to make matters worse, there was the annoying irony. a couple of my coworkers who sensed i did not take the news very well tried to dismiss the idea of grieving, even for a moment, by saying “come on May, she was better off going anyway.”
granted that was true, was it wrong to grieve anyway?
well, not that it was wrong. it was just that there was no time. literally. four patients waited for me, all needing my undivided attention. there was blood pressure to be stabilized, a confused patient to be kept safe, a psychotic patient to be watched, an unresponsive patient whose children were in the corner of the room, crying in frustration and fear had to be monitored. clearly, the last thing all these people needed was a teary eyed nurse, crying for a patient who was not even there anymore.
so i bit my lip, started my night with the same smile i usually start it with, and ended it physically tired and emotionally unfinished. i just didn’t find that moment to grieve. not until now. i know it sounds overly dramatic that i am taking that moment now, away and a long time after the fact, but i am. here, now, where i have the luxury of time.
it’s not that i do not welcome death. it is the uncertainty of when it is coming that i wrestle with. especially with people who seem to have so much more to live for.
it’s not that i do not understand others’ “death-doesn’t-get-to-me” attitude because i do, and have reacted that same way plenty of times. it’s just the fact that sometimes, we are left with no other choice but wear that i-couldn’t-care-less facade just because we don’t have time.
nursing is such a conflicting job sometimes.
we are expected to be human and sensitive so we can take better care of our patients by feeling what they are going through, for their sake.
and yet, we are also expected to detach ourselves from our emotions so we can take care of our patients and make intelligent decisions, also for their sake.
when i think of nurses who have done this for 20 years or more, i wonder how they cope with the conflicting expectations for so long. i wonder how they maintain balance and still be a good nurse. you know, the kind who is not immuned to human emotions but also the kind who does not get overwhelmed by human emotions.


[…] Mike Murray wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptit’s not that i do not understand others’ “death-doesn’t-get-to-me” attitude because i do, and have reacted that same way plenty of times. it’s just the fact that sometimes, we are left with no other choice but wear that … […]
Pingback by 800 NOTES » delayed grieving — November 14, 2007 @ 1:17 pm
i think that’s what makes you such a great nurse may. you care and it shows.
i’m sorry she passed away, but i’m glad you got to know when you did.
Comment by kimmyk — November 14, 2007 @ 2:02 pm
I have been consumed by that grief for my patients. I am not able to detach myself, to turn off that emotion when my patients and families are clearly suffering. It makes the care you give your patients genuine and from your heart. Patients can feel the difference and their families can too.
I am sorry she passed. Cry if you need to. After taking care of your patients, take care of yourself.
Comment by Kathy — November 14, 2007 @ 8:39 pm
Great post, May. I don’t care what you say, or who you are, eventually death gets to everyone - even the strongest of nurses will eventually come across that one patient who they find themselves grieving for. If they don’t, perhaps they shouldn’t be a nurse. After all, grieving is part of humanity, and humanity is the driving force behind a good nurse.
Comment by PD Warrior — November 15, 2007 @ 3:53 am
I’m not a nurse (nor do I play one on TV), but for the past four years I have been privileged to work with nurses in California in my job. I say privileged and mean it. Before I started this position, I had a “patient/family” view and understanding of nurses - the highly visible stuff that takes place in private practice and acute care at the bedside.
But, over the past four years I have seen and learned so much more. May, this post opened my eyes to a part of nursing I haven’t seen before. You made me think about the empathy that great nurses feel for their patients/families and the emotional toll that it exacts. It must be so exhausting working to maintain professional distance when you care for your patients as people, which you very clearly do.
I have come to observe that great nurses care for and ABOUT their patients, but it never dawned on me the price you pay for this. Thanks for opening my eyes a little wider, giving me another peek into your world, and helping me feel there’s a greater good to my work - sharing stories about nurses and helping them to grow and succeed.
Comment by MB, NRN (not an RN) — November 15, 2007 @ 5:12 am
I work in an ED (as a house surgeon) in new zealand, where the nurses are just fantastic - they are so full of caring/compassion (both towards patients us lowly house dogs), despite the awful conditions they work under. it blows me away.
You sound like you’ve been cut from similar cloth - so from all us surly junior doctors, THankyou!
Comment by sam — November 15, 2007 @ 6:30 am
The patient dies, family members say final words, the patient is wrapped. There’s a lot of paperwork to do and phones calls to Organ Procurement sometimes have to be made. Or just to the funeral home.
Within minutes housekeepers have prepered the room for the next patient and a nurse from the E.D. is calling report.
Comment by shrimplate — November 15, 2007 @ 3:23 pm
I’m sorry about your patient. It sounds like she was blessed to have you for her nurse. Blogging about it is a great way to release the grief and is honoring her at the same time.
Comment by SeaSpray — November 15, 2007 @ 11:58 pm
Great post. You have captured why being a nurse is the hardest job in the world, but also the most rewarding. I consider it an honor to be able to grieve for people when everyone around you is going on with business as usual.
Comment by Beth — November 16, 2007 @ 5:12 am
A great post. Never loose the caring, and grieving is ok. If you do it right away, (sometimes it is nice to share it with co workers) sometimes you have to grieve later when there is time.
I have been asked how I do it, but I can’t give a clear answer to it.
Comment by Annemiek — November 16, 2007 @ 5:18 am
I’ve been a nurse almost 28 years and I still get sad when one of my patients dies,if not for them I grieve for the family that will miss them. But you’re right about not having the luxury of grieving at work, I swallow it and go home and try to let it out then. I’ve seen nurses who say death doesn’t bother them anymore,they’re either lying or heartless and need to get another job. Nursing IS such a hard job but I can tell you are an excellent nurse,I’d trust you with myself or family members.
Thanks,May
Comment by Cinder — November 16, 2007 @ 1:44 pm
that is a very deep and insightful post, i enjoy reading your blog, hope to exchange links, mine is http://snpinoy.blogspot.com .happy blogging!
Comment by Tsaiko — November 16, 2007 @ 4:33 pm
I’m glad you took the time to grieve and I would be very afraid of a nurse who didn’t grieve for patients. May you find a hidden blessing amid the sadness.
Onehealthpro
Comment by Onehealthpro — November 16, 2007 @ 4:50 pm
In any book about being a caregiver, whether it’s taking care of Grandma with Alzheimers, or Aunt Mary, who’s dying of cancer, the first thing they tell you is “you have to take care of yourself first”. If you aren’t well, mentally, physically, spiritually, or emotionally, how can you take care of someone else? I truly feel this is especially true for nurses. Do I practice this? Not as I should. But we have to care for ourselves, and allowing yourself to grieve a loss is part of that. You did well by both your patient and yourself.
Comment by Nurse Stella — November 17, 2007 @ 3:27 am
I cry, because I have to let out the sadness, so it doesn’t envelope me.
Sure, our employers think we don’t need time to grieve and that’s a mistake. It’s unfortunate that you have to be crafty and do it on your own time.
One of my patients, the real reason I became a rehab nurse, died in October. I found out two weeks later. It really made me think…whether this was where I wanted to be. I found his obit online and read it and realized I knew most of the people listed there.
I’ve found that I’m going to stay at it and keep plugging along. Everyone finds their way out of this life, and there’s nothing we can do about it. We can make our time with them worthwhile, and real and meaningful, and that is something memorable.
Comment by RehabRN — November 17, 2007 @ 12:06 pm
its nice to know that there are still nurses who still have their humanity in them =)
Comment by Rygel — November 18, 2007 @ 6:58 am
[…] Some patients just “get to you,” and some do so without you realizing it before they’re gone. About a Nurse talks about one such patient and her struggle to find balance when you can’t even grieve yet because there’s still work to be done. […]
Pingback by Mexico Medical Student » Grand Rounds 4:09 — November 20, 2007 @ 2:46 am
Beautiful post May! You brought tears to my eyes with your words. I’m never quite sure when that grief will hit me. There are days that a patient dies and I sob along with the family and barely make it through the day. There are days I just keep it all in until I can get home and cry on the couch with my DH. I always say he really has no idea what I do but after 14 years he has it down pat of when I just need a hug and a cry. You really made me think with this post. Thank you!
Comment by Lisa, RN — November 20, 2007 @ 7:17 pm